Back to the journal

Being partly at fault is not the end of your case

California reduces your recovery by your share of the blame. It does not remove it, and the share is arguable.

Liability

4 min

Reid Callahan

Filed under

Liability

Published

Reading time

4 min

Written by

Reid Callahan

The short version

California reduces recovery by your share of fault — it does not bar it

The percentage is assembled from evidence and is contestable

A police report's view on fault is not binding

Most intersections have an unmarked crosswalk whether or not it is painted

Written by

Reid Callahan

Partner

If any of this is your situation, the call is free and it stays free unless we recover money for you.

The short version

California reduces recovery by your share of fault — it does not bar it

The percentage is assembled from evidence and is contestable

A police report's view on fault is not binding

Most intersections have an unmarked crosswalk whether or not it is painted

Most collisions have more than one cause

A large number of people never call anyone because they believe they were partly to blame. They were going a little fast, they were tired, they crossed where there was no marked crossing. They assume that ends it.

It does not. California applies pure comparative fault: your recovery is reduced by your percentage of responsibility, and nothing more. At forty per cent at fault you recover sixty per cent. There is no cut-off above which you get nothing.

The percentage is an argument, not a fact

Nobody arrives at the scene with a number. It is assembled afterwards from the police report, the physical evidence, the road design, the vehicle data and the accounts of everyone involved. Every one of those inputs is contestable.

Police reports in particular carry more weight in people's minds than they do in law. An officer's opinion on fault is not binding and is frequently formed in fifteen minutes from one side's account.

Where fault often moves

Signal timing at an intersection. Sight lines obstructed by a parked truck or overgrowth. A vehicle's own event data recorder. Whether a crossing that "wasn't marked" was in fact an unmarked crosswalk, which in California it usually is at an intersection.

What this means practically

Do not concede a share of fault to an adjuster on the phone, and do not concede it to yourself. Say what happened, including the parts that do not flatter you, and let the percentage be worked out from evidence.

People talk themselves out of a claim over a share of fault that was never theirs to concede.

What to do next

  • Photograph the scene, including sight lines and any obstruction

  • Request the police report number on the day

  • Tell us the version that does not flatter you — it is the useful one

If any of this is your situation, the call is free and it stays free unless we recover money for you.

This is general information about how these cases usually run in California. It is not advice about your situation, and reading it does not make us your lawyers. Every case turns on its own facts.

We take on the insurers, the paperwork and the phone calls, so you can get on with getting better.

Answering now9:26 AM PT

Reach us

Copy component

Copied

hello@injuria.law

1 Sansome Street, Suite 3500
San Francisco, CA 94104

© 2026 Injuria LLP

Attorney advertising

Past results do not guarantee a similar outcome

We take on the insurers, the paperwork and the phone calls, so you can get on with getting better.

Answering now9:26 AM PT

Reach us

Copy component

Copied

hello@injuria.law

1 Sansome Street, Suite 3500
San Francisco, CA 94104

© 2026 Injuria LLP

Attorney advertising

Past results do not guarantee a similar outcome

Back to the journal

Being partly at fault is not the end of your case

California reduces your recovery by your share of the blame. It does not remove it, and the share is arguable.

Liability

4 min

Reid Callahan

Filed under

Liability

Published

Reading time

4 min

Written by

Reid Callahan

The short version

California reduces recovery by your share of fault — it does not bar it

The percentage is assembled from evidence and is contestable

A police report's view on fault is not binding

Most intersections have an unmarked crosswalk whether or not it is painted

Written by

Reid Callahan

Partner

If any of this is your situation, the call is free and it stays free unless we recover money for you.

The short version

California reduces recovery by your share of fault — it does not bar it

The percentage is assembled from evidence and is contestable

A police report's view on fault is not binding

Most intersections have an unmarked crosswalk whether or not it is painted

Most collisions have more than one cause

A large number of people never call anyone because they believe they were partly to blame. They were going a little fast, they were tired, they crossed where there was no marked crossing. They assume that ends it.

It does not. California applies pure comparative fault: your recovery is reduced by your percentage of responsibility, and nothing more. At forty per cent at fault you recover sixty per cent. There is no cut-off above which you get nothing.

The percentage is an argument, not a fact

Nobody arrives at the scene with a number. It is assembled afterwards from the police report, the physical evidence, the road design, the vehicle data and the accounts of everyone involved. Every one of those inputs is contestable.

Police reports in particular carry more weight in people's minds than they do in law. An officer's opinion on fault is not binding and is frequently formed in fifteen minutes from one side's account.

Where fault often moves

Signal timing at an intersection. Sight lines obstructed by a parked truck or overgrowth. A vehicle's own event data recorder. Whether a crossing that "wasn't marked" was in fact an unmarked crosswalk, which in California it usually is at an intersection.

What this means practically

Do not concede a share of fault to an adjuster on the phone, and do not concede it to yourself. Say what happened, including the parts that do not flatter you, and let the percentage be worked out from evidence.

People talk themselves out of a claim over a share of fault that was never theirs to concede.

What to do next

  • Photograph the scene, including sight lines and any obstruction

  • Request the police report number on the day

  • Tell us the version that does not flatter you — it is the useful one

If any of this is your situation, the call is free and it stays free unless we recover money for you.

This is general information about how these cases usually run in California. It is not advice about your situation, and reading it does not make us your lawyers. Every case turns on its own facts.

We take on the insurers, the paperwork and the phone calls, so you can get on with getting better.

Answering now9:26 AM PT

Reach us

Copy component

Copied

hello@injuria.law

1 Sansome Street, Suite 3500
San Francisco, CA 94104

© 2026 Injuria LLP

Attorney advertising

Past results do not guarantee a similar outcome

Create a free website with Framer, the website builder loved by startups, designers and agencies.